Newly-minted TERFgoblin alert
Heads-up for people who may have to deal with her:
Jill Bearup of “Stuff You Like” fame appears to have gone full TERF. In a recent post, she misrepresents an incident where professional transphobe Maria MacLachlan assaulted a much smaller woman at an LGBT event and put her in a headlock, which lead to her being elbowed in self-defense. Bearup uses the warped and incorrect “innocent old lady assaulted by savage men” version put forth by MacLachlan and her ilk. She also prefaces said post with a link to an article called “The Careful, Pragmatic Case Against Punching Nazis“, so it appears that yet semi-famous internet personality shows her true (and indeed very pragmatic) face when it’s become profitable and acceptable to side with fascists and oppressors.I suggest for everyone who may be targeted by transphobic violence to steer clear of her.
Sad to say, this is true. http://jillbearup.com/post/165633676124/if-you-strike-them-down-they-will-become-more
She even repeats talking points about transwomen (who she refers to by their genitalia) going into toilets (public restrooms), much the way Right Wing Republicans did last year with the unconstitutional HB 2 to create the narrative that transwomen are just men looking to target “our daughters” for sexual assault when in reality transwomen are much more likely to BE attacked than to attack anyone in public restrooms. https://www.bustle.com/p/what-really-happens-when-a-trans-woman-uses-a-public-restroom-40417 As in, as that article points out, “there are zero reported cases of trans people attacking others in public restrooms[.]”
Oh, and she calls the term TERF a slur. And suggests putting a transwoman in a male prison. Which studies show tends to lead to rape. Of the transwoman. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_people_in_prison#Physical_and_sexual_abuse
As such, unless she walks back and apologizes (doubtful, given that, as a colleague of mine pointed out, “There’s so much detail in it that it can only be deliberate that the chokehold was left out.“) I will no longer be posting her content on the Chez Apocalypse fan Tumblr.
I’d certainly like for this to just be a blip and that she’s really better than that post I linked to implies, but I’m not hopeful. A shame too, as Stuff You Like was often a top priority show for me for the past few years; meaning I would often watch the new episode almost as soon as it showed up in my Subscriptions, sometimes even pausing whatever podcast or Spotify playlist I was in the middle of to watch it. :(
For the past 5 days, I’ve struggled with how I address this here on this page. I didn’t think just sharing what I’d written on my personal page in response to Creature’s post was adequate.
Unfortunately, I’m not sure what else I can say. Jill is a monster. She repeats the kind of rhetoric that in my country has led to cismen to storm women’s restrooms under the guise of “protecting girls” from transwomen. The kind of rhetoric that has led to the murder of transwomen in my country being at epidemic levels the past two years (and that’s just what I’m aware of). She wants to put trans women in men’s prisons where they’re all but guaranteed to get raped. She uses the outdated word transsexual. She calls the term TERF a slur.
It’s not surprising that her post has taken off in transphobic circles, including people who casually throw around the actual slur “tr***y”. And when I looked at the post again today before writing this, to double check my own comments, I couldn’t help but notice that some comments critical of her were missing.
She is spreading falsehoods to protect hateful people and hurt disadvantaged people, which is in direct contradiction of what I understand to be the core characteristics of Chez. After all, apart from entertaining, it’s also meant to educate. Right?
So effective this past Friday, September 22nd, 2017, Jill Bearup and her content are no longer welcome on this page. Chez has a large number of LGBTQ fans, and they deserve better. As for past posts, I am seriously considering going back and removing them all.
I loved her show. Her pro-fan fiction videos over the years inspired me to not only follow through with a massive fic project I’d done but also to be proud of it without hiding behind my AO3 and FFN pseudonym. I read Grand Central Arena on her recommendation. I take no pleasure in this. I’m not the kind of person who just sits around and waits for Internet Famous people to fuck up so I can knock them off their pedestals. This hurts. This just fucking hurts. :(
And somehow I managed to forget to actually post it TO this blog as opposed to my personal one. *sigh*
